A German MEP’s viral comment sparks debate: Could Canada join the EU? Here’s what it would mean, and why the idea isn’t as wild as it sounds.
EU Crossover Comment Sparks Debate in Canada
A viral comment from a German Member of the European Parliament has ignited online debate across Canada. On June 7, MEP David McAllister suggested—half in jest—that Canada “would be more than welcome” to join the European Union. Though the remark wasn’t official EU policy, it sparked thousands of shares, reactions, and editorial pieces, with Canadians asking: could this ever happen?
Why the Comment Hit a Nerve
The post went viral within hours, especially on X and Reddit, where users cited Canada’s strong democratic values, close trade ties with Europe, and growing disillusionment with U.S. politics. While Canada is geographically distant from Europe, it already shares a robust economic and cultural relationship through the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), in effect since 2017.
Historical Ties and Modern Momentum
Canada has deep-rooted European connections, particularly with the UK, France, and Germany. Its parliamentary system and bilingualism further reflect European influence. Economically, EU-Canada trade totaled over $100 billion in 2023. While there’s no precedent for a non-European country joining the EU, some commentators argue that Canada is closer to Brussels in values and vision than some current members.
Legal and Political Roadblocks
Despite the enthusiasm, experts warn the idea is more fantasy than feasible. The EU’s treaties currently require geographic proximity and shared borders, among other criteria. Moreover, joining the EU would mean ceding some national authority to Brussels—a controversial move for any sovereign country. Canadian and EU officials have so far made no formal comment on the suggestion.
What Canadians Are Saying
“Should Canada ever consider joining the EU?” As of June 10, results show a nation divided:
- Yes: 42%
- No: 45%
- Not Sure: 13%
In social media conversations, proponents highlight shared values and economic opportunity, while critics raise sovereignty concerns and logistical impracticalities.
A Conversation Worth Having
While the prospect of Canada joining the EU remains remote, the reaction reflects a deeper sentiment—one of shifting global alliances, and Canada’s role in the international order. As geopolitical tensions rise, particularly with China and Russia, Canadians may be more open to exploring alternative strategic alignments.