Judge to Rule on High-Profile Hockey Case This Week
A landmark verdict is expected Thursday in London, Ontario, as five former members of Canada’s 2018 World Junior hockey team await the court’s ruling in a sexual assault trial that has rocked the Canadian sports world.
Details of the Alleged Incident and Initial Response
The case stems from a June 2018 incident at the Delta Hotel in London following a Hockey Canada fundraising gala. A woman alleged that eight players from the national junior team sexually assaulted her while she was intoxicated and vulnerable. A relative contacted police at the time, but the original investigation was closed in 2019 without charges.
Renewed Legal Action and Public Outcry
In 2022, the woman filed a civil suit seeking $3.55 million in damages. The case, which was settled privately by Hockey Canada, prompted national outrage after it emerged that the organization had secret funds to cover sexual misconduct claims. The public backlash forced police to reopen the investigation, ultimately leading to criminal charges against five players.
Players Charged and Court Proceedings
The charged players—Carter Hart, Michael McLeod, Cal Foote, Dillon Dube, and Alex Formenton—have all pleaded not guilty. McLeod also faces an additional charge of being a party to the offense. Each has since been removed from NHL rosters or lacks an active contract, pending the outcome of the trial.
Testimonies and Legal Arguments
During the May 2025 proceedings, the woman testified that she was coerced into sexual acts out of fear, stating she felt the only “safe” option was compliance. Defense lawyers argued that she had willingly participated and sought a “wild night.” The emotional testimonies have drawn national attention and reignited calls for accountability in Canadian hockey.
Verdict to Be Delivered by Judge Alone
Justice Maria Carroccia of Ontario Superior Court will issue the verdict without a jury. In May, she dismissed the jury over concerns about potential bias after complaints that defense attorneys had mocked jurors. The case will now rest solely in her hands.
Potential Consequences and Broader Impacts
If convicted, the players could face sentences of up to 10 years under Canadian law. Even if acquitted, their NHL futures remain uncertain, with Commissioner Gary Bettman stating the league will act based on the final outcome. Past NHL disciplinary actions suggest the league may intervene regardless of legal conclusions.
Damage to Hockey Canada’s Reputation and Leadership
Hockey Canada has already faced severe fallout. Major sponsors, including Nike, withdrew support, and the entire board and CEO resigned in 2022. The case has spurred national debate on institutional accountability and the culture of silence in Canadian sports.
Looking Ahead
The verdict on Thursday could mark a turning point in how sports organizations handle sexual assault allegations. The NHL has committed to transparency, though final steps depend on the legal outcome. The case underscores growing pressure for reform across Canadian athletics.
Source: Maple News Wire, July 23, 2025
